Report released March 29, 2010
Often adults think that children and youth don’t have the capacity to express themselves or make good decisions. I’ve been working with kids for a long time and I wholeheartedly disagree. It makes me cringe when I hear adults making a big fuss out of something intelligent that a child or a young person says.
I’m not amazed anymore when kids say something profound or brilliant – I’ve come to expect it. When trusted and given a comfortable space to say what they think, children and young people tend to bring critical insights to a situation, especially when it’s one that directly impacts on them and their lives.
So when adults are designing and implementing programs, instead of assuming that they know what is best for children and youth, it’s a good idea to actually ask them and involve them.
The “Children’s Voices in the PDNA” project (implemented by Plan with support from UNICEF) did exactly that: experienced Haitian facilitators developed a child friendly methodology to consult with 54 groups of children and youth – almost 1000 kids in total – in 9 departments in Haiti to find out what they wanted to see in the new Haiti. The resulting document in full can be found here, and is well worth a look-through.
The consultations focused on a few broad areas:
- the impact of the January 2010 earthquake on children’s and youth’s lives and that of their communities
- their visions for the reconstruction and long-term development of their country
- their views regarding their present situations and future risks they may face
- their ideas on how they would like to participate the future development of their country.
The project aimed at not only gathering opinions and ideas from the participating children and youth to feed into the PDNA, but to help them understand the PDNA process and how it would link into the long-term reconstruction in Haiti and impact on their own lives. Children and youth were also given the space to share ideas for accountability, monitoring and evaluation mechanisms.
Participants were divided into age-based groups (5-10, 11-16 and 17-24 year olds) for the consultations, and their responses were recorded according to sex in order to ensure that gender-based information was available for future program planning. The 4 main categories of the PDNA were included as well: social sectors, infrastructure, production sectors, and governance/security. In order to ensure a holistic approach when coming up with solutions, the root causes of vulnerability and risk were discussed. Environmental hazards such as earthquakes, floods, landslides, and social risks like child trafficking, child protection, violence and abuse were addressed. A summary of the children and youths priorities by age and sex is found on page 19 of the document.
Children and youth certainly had something to say.
——————–
“I want a different Haiti where we, the youth, have a chance to participate with the government; we can be part of the government and of all activities in the country. In the past, youth had been completely excluded; we need a new strategy or approach to achieve this end.” Boy in age group 11-16, Croix des Bouquets
“I’m sure we’ll have a better Haiti with the participation of youth and children. Then, Haiti would become a beautiful country. Haiti cannot be rebuilt without the participation of children and youth, we are Haiti’s present, we will be Haiti’s future.” Girl in age group 11-16yrs, Croix des Bouquets
“After the earthquake, I have seen a deprived youth. The country had assumed a thinking mind on behalf of Haitian youth. Because in my vision, I saw there was no future for the youth. We need to make men act consciously to facilitate equal distribution of things and to help every citizen according to his needs. My advice would be to decentralize the country, think of the whole country and rebuild the country consciously. Awareness is crucial to achieve a better distribution of international aid so it can benefit those most in need.” 22 year old male, Cyvadier / South-East
“First, the focus group was a very good activity; everyone was involved and conscientious. Everyone had the opportunity to express their ideas and opinions freely. About January 12, I think everyone has his or her own way to live, understand and explain this event. But, there is still confusion and fear among people. They are traumatized and desperate. Now, we must reconsider, give room for everyone, listen to every person with positive ideas in the context of the reconstruction.” 18 year old female, Department of the West
——————–
Permission for two of the participating youth to attend a March 30th Side Event called “A Haiti Fit for Children” and to participate in the March 31st Donors Conference (both held in New York City), was granted. Ironically, the youth were denied visas to enter the US. In my last post about Haiti I asked “Will Haitian youth go missing again?” The answer is “yes.” But at least we can hope that their voices in written form will reach the eyes and ears of decision makers and donors. I hope that they will listen. Children under 18 make up around 50% of the population in Haiti… if they go unheard, that is a lot of missing voices.
If you are reading this blog post and you plan to launch an initiative in Haiti, I hope you also will take 15 minutes to read through the “Children and Young People’s Voices in Haiti’s Post Disaster Needs Assessment” to hear what these 1000 children and youth in Haiti have to say.
But not only that. I hope that before doing anything on the ground in Haiti, you or someone that you are working with will directly talk with and listen to Haitian children and young people, as well as with their parents, teachers, community leaders, and others in the communities that you are hoping to help or support.
Related posts on Wait… What?
Will Haitian youth go missing again?
Children in Emergencies: Applying what we already know to the crisis in Haiti
Read Full Post »
Wait... What? 